On Vagina by Naomi Wolf and the reviews that followed

30 Flares 30 Flares ×

 On Vagina by Naomi Wolf and the reviews that followedThe release of Naomi Wolf’s “Vagina: A New Biography” was met with scathing criticisms from feminists like Laurie Penny, Ariel Levy and Zoe Heller. These influential writers all bring up some valid arguments about problematic ideas presented in the book. Vagina is indeed a book that in many ways feels unfinished and often naïve.
It is in a sense two parallel books in one: The first part tests the validity of the obvious idea that the brain and the vagina are connected while the second – if still incomplete – is much more interesting and true to the title looking at historical ideas about female sexuality.

However, frankly what is even more frustrating than Naomi Wolf’s tendency to draw premature conclusions based on incomplete research and then furthermore present platitudes as though they were revelations, is that even though she doesn’t fully succeed, her attempt to honestly and critically discuss female sexuality is met with reviews that take it too far with their vitriolic and personal criticism.

As a black/African feminist, I find myself in familiar territory reading the reviews. The gatekeepers of mainstream feminism’s underlying message is still that firstly, there is just one kind of feminist dialogue and women who don’t fit into this box may not contribute to it and, secondly, that the conversation should be of the type of Cartesian, unemotional writing that is held above all other types of social discourse in western society.

While the hole-as-goddess language that Naomi Wolf employs is over the top for me personally, what’s laudable is the endeavour to connect women’s erotic and sensual lives with their creativity and power.
However, it is therefore important to emphasize that this is a discussion that feminists before, especially those from the south and black feminists around the world have been having for decades. Black feminists have necessarily sought women’s own re/interpretations of sexuality in creative, erotic and spiritual realms of painting, pottery, poetry and so on because heavily male- dominant and often racially oppressive worlds of academic and historical “truths” do not account ‘herstory’ or African heritage reliably.

In 1978, Audre Lorde for example urged women to find our “internal erotic guides” and explore the erotic as a source of power. In African Sexualities, Nkiru Nzegwu describes that unlike the dominant ideas in 20th century sexology, in Osunality (or African eroticism) the penis is not in charge. Instead, the vagina is seen as the dominant organ as it swallows the penis, it pulls it and makes it disappear during heterosexual sex. (This is comparable to the ‘upsuck theory’ that Naomi Wolf discusses.)

In other words, there are much better resources that attempt to connect intimacy with a form of female knowing (as in the links above) than Naomi Wolf’s

Apart from continuing to reject the idea that cerebral thinking is more of a guarantee for profundity than is knowledge that has its seeds in emotion, soulfulness and creativity, I hope we will continue to explore connections between women’s creative and erotic lives as an antidote to woman-bashing in our hypersexualized society. I also think that we should seek counter-narratives of the penis as an erotic symbol of maleness and explore how that is psychosexually related to ideas of male power. Oh, I wrote a post about that a while ago - male genitalia and ideas of power. I also wrote about somatic approaches to psychology (which is really what we are dealing with here,)and of how prejudices against African spiritual philosophy for example, continue despite evidence that there is knowledge available in this field that modern science is only just beginning to understand.

Have you read it? What’s your take?

pixel On Vagina by Naomi Wolf and the reviews that followed
30 Flares Facebook 10 Twitter 13 LinkedIn 5 Pin It Share 0 Google+ 2 Email -- Reddit 0 StumbleUpon 0 Buffer 0 30 Flares ×
  • http://www.waikiharnais.com Waiki

    Osunality … I have just learned a new word! Thanks for sharing this review. I don’t think I will bother with the book.

  • MsAfropolitan

    Thanks for the comment Waiki!

    Coincidentally, I’ve found myself quoting the book a few times since reading it so I can’t encourage to entirely dismiss it but to read critically to an extent.

  • http://www.freespoken.net Sally

    Love the critique and the introduction to “Osunality”. Great piece!

  • akhumo

    I stumbled across your blog quite by accident… and I must say, I am rather pleased with myself. I have gone through a few of your articles and one word: WOW! As a young South African black woman (slowly stepping out of the closet I might add), your blog is officially now my second most favourite place to be in the world (the first is a secret). I look forward to more of your thoughts and views… I don’t doubt for a second my eyes will be lookin deeper and further into the essence womanhod and life as a whole! Thank You!

    • MsAfropolitan

      Thanks for the kind note Akhumo, it’s a pleasure to have your company. Congrats on your decision to step out of the closet- it takes courage to fully be ourselves unfortunately still in this world.

      Minna